I absolutely love this podcast!! I am new to listening, but I feel like Nic’s an old friend telling me stories and keeping me company. I love all your stories, one day I will share mine. 🌺Carrie Michigan 〽️

This sounds like a high school kid rush reading a paper out loud. No inflection or change in tone through the monotone readings. It is so difficult to listen to this. These stories would be wonderful if people who provided the stories told the stories themselves—or the reader slowed down and incorporated some inflection and appropriate tone to the stories. Instead it sounds like he is reading off recipes off the back of a box of something. I really hope this review is taken as constructive criticism—-it could be a really good show.

This is one of the best paranormal podcasts out there! Nic Ryan has the best speaking voice, plus he always has the best stories! Don’t waste time on hocus-pocus tales. These are the ones you can relate to, the kind that are so real you’ll sleep with the lights on afterwards!

Hi anyone who reads this. I recently came across this podcast when I was bored. I started listening to the podcasts and realized that a lot of these stories were really interesting. Some of them are similar to some of the events that I have went through. Anyway, I love this podcast and I think that anyone interested in the supernatural- should listen to all of it :) Also- a message to the many haters. Hello fellow haters. This is my message to you. You can watch and or listen to whatever you want. But don’t accuse others of that their stories are fake. You never know.

the stories are so entertaining! and i love hearing other people’s story. there is a couple times where i feel like it’s a simple animal like a wolf or a coyote but beside that i love it!

Who are the people giving this guy with the monotone voice 5 stars. So boring.

This show is fantastic and a lot of the experiences shared here have encouraged me to deal with what is going on in my own home. Thank you for giving this space for sharing. It does seem like there are quite a few recordings of coyotes that are being claimed as Bigfoot. Its very distinct, dog/hyena like. A little research on coyote sounds could prevent a lot of this. I have coyotes in my back valley every single night and they have a very broad vocalization capabilities.

I don’t know why but the extended music at the end of each show seems really excessive. I use podcasts to help me sleep at night and the music wakes me. Otherwise the podcast is soothing to listen to.

I’m so glad you’re back! Hope the move is going a bit smoother. I’ve really missed you. This is my favorite podcast, you really are the best out here. No nonsense, no rambling on just to hear yourself talk, straight to the point and you really do your research. Keep up the amazing work! ♥️

I listened to the doppelgänger and shadow people episode and that was a truly creepy story. I have a slight memory of a two dimensional being that would appear like the one in the story. I can’t really recall specifics but I remember the uncanniness of it and being really scared because i knew it was trying to look real. I really hope the story is true. I love this podcast.

Fake stories from wannabe horror authors. Don’t waste your time.

He is always great to listen to. Great storytelling and easy to understand. Keep up the great work!

I have listened to many podcasts where they use a voicemail format but this was kinda bad ngl. I listen for multiple stories not a biography of one woman. It was frustrating when I would skip over halfway through an episode and it’s still the same person talking. I do think the stories you read and the shorter voice mails are very interesting and I thoroughly enjoy these… But, I don’t like how some stories are re uploaded as a “rewind”. I have my selection under Unplayed and I download episodes on my way to work as I get no service. So I’m sure you can understand my annoyance when I download episodes I’ve already played.

All of the stories are so good and they are scary but not so scary. I like that you can send your own story and he will read them.

If you are going to present the listeners experiences in their own voices please don’t allow one listener to call back repeatedly and dominate the whole podcast. This first one in early January was the worst podcast I’ve listened to so far.

This is a great podcast 100/10 the best one I’ve listened to

Found this podcast a little bit ago and it has become my go to for listening to paranormal stories of all kinds. Absolutely love having it playing in the background listening to everybody’s experiences and the narration is perfect. Still got about 200 episodes to go before I’m fully caught up so I can’t wait to hear what else is in store.

I just finished listening to every episode and absolutely loved them the stories are very interesting to listen to and they are narrated well! This podcast feels like a very safe place for people’s experiences. -AustinLane

Binge worthy podcast. His voice is amazing for narrating and the stories are so interesting. The podcast is a safe place for people to share their stories.

I love this podcast because he gives us a place to share our stories without being judged. I love how he reads them to us and we get to enter our own stories easily.

I just want the host to know how much I appreciate he doesn’t force his listeners to become a “paid subscriber” to listen to certain episodes as so many podcasters now do. He kindly asks if you would like to donate you can and doesn’t force you. THANK YOU! You are such a breath of fresh air as not all of us can afford to pay $5-$15 a month for all their favorite podcasts. Your content is amazing and I am a loyal listener. Keep making content. 🖤

I’m a big fan of the paranormal and found this podcast and immediately was hooked. Now after being a regular follower, I’m finding there are a lot of repeats and rewinds. I get that he’s working on another show, but why not focus on what’s working for you now? Ah well, just tired of the same stories. Maybe I’ll check back at a later time…

This is such a great podcast! My only complaint is the episodes aren’t longer! Always a great listen though.

I like your show a lot and really like when you have stories from SC

The only effort that the host puts in is in monitoring his email inbox, and he happily reads whatever nonsensical story makes it past his spam filter from people looking for their 15-minutes online fame without any sort of investigation, verification, or truth seeking. It is not so much a podcast as it is a post office, because there’s nothing else than a collection of letters.

I really love listening to this podcast! It’s my favorite! I recommend it to anyone who is interested in paranormal and enjoys listening to others views on their experiences.

I absolutely love this show! I like to hear the paranormal experiences of others. Nic does such a great job with the narrations.

I loved this podcast but I can no longer watch it because of it being age restricted.

These stories are very lame.

I am a new listener. You recently played some older episodes that I really enjoyed. Your voice was more natural sounding in your early shows. I prefer that. I like your format and your content. I prefer a quiet natural sounding conversational cadence for this genre of podcast.

I really enjoy these stories! Very creepy. I listen to these in the car and I don’t notice the long drives as much because these are so entertaining. Keep up the spooky stores!!

Wow mind blown!!!!! I'm really digging this but I lost it when he said one or two of the hikers tongue ripped out or ate out by some type of bacteria and had no eyes!!!!!! Like what?!

This guys cadence is the same as the Pet Rat Gummi Candy video and it can’t be unheard. 🤣

I’m so happy I found your podcast. I love learning & listening. Your one about a Ouija board was very enlightening. Thank you. It was also short and sweet right to the point. I’m excited I have a awful lot to listen to. Thank you so much for doing such a great job..!

I really like listening to this. I’d give it a five except I can’t stand the three minutes of music at the end of each episode.

Hi Nick, I really liked the last episode about the Moth man, the way you narrated was very pleasant and natural. Thank you for all the work you do.

I only listened to some of two episodes before I had enough. Just stories submitted by listeners. I was hoping for weird events that were researched but this is more like generic campfire stories.

I found this podcast recently and have really enjoyed the diversity. I grew up in southwest Michigan and had no ideas about the stories in the area. I grew up in a haunted house on Saddle Lake. I never realized how unique it was till I went off to school at Michigan State. I moved to Texas at the end of university and have had only a couple of paranormal since the early 80s but the house I grew up in it was a weekly if not daily experiences. Thx for all your hard work!

I’ve seen paranormal counters in my life is there a creepy one almost killed me like it almost gave me a heart attack but anyway, this is a great show

Everything is already perfect!

One of my favorite podcasts ❤️

Huge fan!

I really identified with the old hag story. I’ve had many of these episodes, and I’m a sane person but truly find them to be paranormal. Especially when said episodes have left me physically harmed.

This podcast is a must if you like the paranormal and a great place to share your story because there’s no judgment and Nick is open to anything.

Really enjoy this podcast, the narration and your kind, empathetic demeanor, Nic. For those of us paying attention, we know you’ve been going through a life transition, hope it brings all good things to you, and realize that the podcast has had to take a temporary back seat. Your fans can be patient as you and your family settle into your new home! Thanks for all you do! Update: Excited that new episodes are dropping regularly again, but I miss the old opening theme music a little bit 😪

I love this podcast. Always interesting . Nic Ryan is a great host . The topics are always good and keep my interest .

Hello Nic, i came across your podcast after taking a break of my usual due to being caught up for the 2nd time. I never thought I’d enjoy another podcast that would intrigue my curiosities. I give you 👍🏻👍🏻 Love your podcast!

This is the most amazing podcast (and one of the only) that I have listened to. I find nic’s voice so relaxing.

One of the best podcasts. I’ve finished the entire cast. Now I re listen when I good to bed!

I listen to this while trying to sleep, not a good idea I know, and it’s so interesting and Nic’s voice is nice so I find it relaxing. However, I was listening to the cinematic ghost story episode, and I was almost asleep. Then the part where it says “Talk to me” IT SOUNDED LIKE IT WAS IN THE ROOM. It woke me up so much! It was scary haha. Anyway, this is a very entertaining podcast! Definitely Recommended.