I get a surge of joy ever time an episode drops. I’m an American gal, but the witty things that fall out of these ladies mouths makes me laugh and feel seen. It’s the lightest way to talk about the dark.

Omg! I have listened to them all but, this episode had me laughing so hard! Thank you after events of this week it helped.

As a fellow podcaster I can be super picky, in fact this is the 1st review I have ever posted on itunes, I just had to take a minute to tell Jen Sophie and Cassie how entertaining I find you. You each bring a unique voice and style to the cast. Since I have almost run out of episodes I’m almost tempted to listen to your Mommy podcast! Keep up the good work. P.S. contrary to popular opinion you do have some male listeners, and an American to boot! P.P.S. My podcast is called truecrimebreakdown if your in the mood for some real true crime!!

I just found this podcast and it feels like I’ve found my brethren. Love listening to these Irish ladies chat about the things I Google late at night. Sending much love from an American fan who understands 90% of all references made…there dozens of us American fans. DOZENS!

I keep recommending this podcast to everyone. I’ve gotten through the regular episodes and now need to joint the patreon to get the content from there. Love from Wisconsin ❤️

I’ve been with you ladies since the beginning. I’m in Washington state in the US and you have made me laugh more than I can verbalize, I’ve peed laugh. Love Mother of Pod too! Keep being ridiculous. Cassie your calm voice is awesome, Jen you are smart and so witty and Sofie, no words, you are glorious! Love you ladies do so much!!

My friend got me hooked on this Podcast. Accidentally started off with the John Wayne Bobbitt episode and immediately reconsidered said friendship. I wasn’t quite prepared for the gusto the three ladies tell their stories with. Gave it another go. And another. And have become not just low key obsessed with their humorous, insightful way of giving me my creep fix. The Irish accent is a bonus for me. Love y’all!

amazing sense of humor

Listen, I’m a 30 year old mother of 3 and I finally feel like maybe I’m not so weird. I’ve always been unbelievably fascinated with true crime and with that came a dry and obscene sense of humor. These women are my people. This podcast cured my COVID depression by giving me something to look forward to in the monotony of never leaving my house. You’re doing great lady’s. Thank you!

at first i thought oh but now i’m like OHHH

My new favorite podcast is A Toast to Toast.

women talking . i love it

These ladies are wonderful. If you haven’t started listening... do it. Do it NOW!

...can’t actually recall how I was brought to this beauty of a podcast, but I’m here now and you should be too. The ladies are brilliant and never fail to perfectly acquaint us with all the “creeps”. Love the down to earth delivery of content and the accents are tops. If you like the peculiar or the bewildering, do yourself a favor and give this a go.

As a mother of pod listener I had heard of the creep dive being mentioned but never listened to an episode, although always meant to start. I started my first episode 2 weeks ago and I’ve only 6 episodes left. I went back and listened to nearly all the creep dives in reverse order from newest to the oldest ones - and I’m loving it. Have 2 of my Irish co-workers also hooked and we’re working in New York. We’ll have to get our American colleagues on board next. Keep the deep dives into the creeps coming, can’t get enough. Can’t wait until your live shows goes international 😊

These women deliver creepy with a fantastic mix of wit, humor, and banter. Keeps me laughing and entertained. The Irish version of Karen & Georgia (plus one more). Love.

I love listening to the stories and it’s a great mix of light and dark. The girls have great banter!

Absolutely love this podcast. Helps me get through work and also get weird stares from my coworkers as I laugh out loud and make weird faces. I love the commentary and conversations that makes me wish I was friends with these 3 women during my time living abroad in Ireland.

I love these ladies so much. Their accents are very pleasant to my Missouri ears. I LOVED Cassie’s story about her guardian angel Moe. Y’all are amazing at what you do. Keep up the great work! -Jamie

Recently found this podcast and I have non stop binged! Love listening to the girls banter, makes me miss home a little less!

One of my favorite podcasts, they’re all so funny.

Thanks to your hard work, I have many a creepy story to bring out at parties!

Great banter between the girls and great mix of cases!

The hosts combine horror, hilarity and the strangeness of humanity PERFECTLY. Voices make for easy listening and is intriguing everytime. Click in!

Jen is my spirit animal! Podcast is brilliant keep it up guys 😁😁