I just found this podcast today. I recently rewatched both seasons for the summertime of course. And I started looking for more content because I keep getting pulled into this world and don’t want to leave! I love how detailed and in depth each episode review is. I started at the very beginning of your episodes and am already on episode 6. Love this so much.

Thank you both for keeping us all entertained and invested while we wait (forever and infinity) for Season 3! This pod is exactly what I needed and I’m so glad I found you guys!

This is a good SITP podcast, but my only critique is that it would be nice if the host was more unbiased and not so obviously Team Conrad

A great listen for anyone seeking more TSITP content. I really enjoy their conversation back and forth and appreciate how Vicki clearly has a fav (#TeamConrad) she doesn’t bash other characters and sees strengths and flaws in each person.

Great pod! Love your analysis and really enjoyed the fanfic episode!

I enjoy listening to the show but it’s definitely Team Conrad and I would enjoy a more biased review of the show.

💕💕💕 all my love. You already know!!

Love that Vicky pushes back, I disagreed si strongly with Casey saying that Conrad isn’t at his peak of wanting Belly, also episode 2.6 his read on Conrad’s apology at the party store was super off! There’s no way Conrad was feeling guilty for bringing Audrey up there, I think it happened exactly as Conrad said!

Love listening to your thoughts and views on this show. Can’t get enough. Great job!

My only complaint is that the volume of the podcast is really low. I have to turn the podcast up almost all the way just for it to sound normal volume. Besides that I love the podcast!!

So I’m late to this podcast because I was also late finding the show but I’m not late now and all filled in. I read the books years ago so I have some background. I will say Vicky does a great job at the recaps. I have listened to the recap episodes more than once because I think the more I watch the show the more I get out of each episode of this podcast. I’m not so patiently waiting to hear her take on the beginning of season 2. I will also say I sometimes feel too old to be watching this show but Vicky helps normalize that. My only beef would be when Casey dissed Dartmouth in the mail bag episode. That campus is absolutely beautiful. Thank you guys for feeding my guilty pleasure.

love listening to this whenever! i'm so busy being a 17 year old cheerleader and whenever i get stressed out this is perfect! it's like sitting down and talking about my favorite show with my best friends!💕 *and the saved by the bell reference in the 6th episode review......i loved it!!!*💕💕💕💕💕love yall!

love the show!