I love this podcast. They tell great stories at the perfect speed for me to really get into them. I found the episode on the recent drone activity in NJ chilling because they gave a different perspective which I never thought of, or heard on other podcasts. I live in Northern NJ which has had a lot of the activity- still does! Thank you to all involved in this great podcast. I LOVE IT!

Bring Ashley Back

The new host have to go, no offense, but they lose my attention quickly. Bring back Ashley! Who agrees?

I missed when Ashley did this show too but the new girls grow on you. I think since there is such a big contrast between how Ashley hosts/ her cadence and Yvette and Rasha’s hosting/cadence it’s hard to see it as the same show. Once you start thinking of it as Yvette and Rashas podcast they do start to grow on you. I like the topics and the energy the girls bring to each story. Good job, will keep listening. 💕

Listeners have spoken. Please drop the new hosts! Do it for the fans.

Look, I’m not even a fan of Ashley Flowers, but her storytelling abilities far surpass these new hosts, and this podcast has taken a major hit. They are terrible. I’m gonna tell you something that I wish Ashley and more podcasters and other entertainers understood, we don’t care about you. At all. Entertain us. We are here for the subject matter. That is what you are there for, and that is all we want from you. When your personal opinions get involved, everyone stops caring. May sound mean but at least someone is telling you the truth.

I listen to all of the audio chuck podcasts so of course I miss Ashley as much as the next person, but I don’t understand all the hate with Rasha and Yvette. They have so much personality and I love hearing them talk. I even love listening to their personal stories; it adds to the story and breaks up the monotony and makes it feel like they’re not just reading from a script.

I hate leaving negative reviews but I can’t avoid this one. :( The new hosts are turning me off to this show. At this point I’m going back and listening to old ones Ashley did on repeat. The other comments cover all the reasons why - I can see I’m not the only one. Plz bring Ashley back!

I’ve been a big fan of So Supernatural for a few years and when the new hosts took over, I gave it a shot. It’s just not the same and the new hosts just don’t do the show justice.

I loved this show when Ashley hosted! I tried to like this, really I gave it a shot. This is poorly done and the new hosts sound like clueless teenage girls. I had to shut it off. Can we get a host who can tell a story? I love Ashley and Deliah. Please give us someone new

The new hosts ruined, one of my favorite shows. They talk too much about themselves that no one asked for. Stick to the topic.

The new girls gotta go

When do the advertisers start pulling? Bringing Ashley back won't save this podcast. The damage is done.

idk what everyone is talking about i really like the new hosts, ashley is cool but she has a lot of other podcasts she hosts & these girls have a lot of personality & their experiences with their mom make it more interesting. i like the way they put things into perspective & catch your attention please don’t change them!

I’ve listened to the old Supernatural episodes at least twice and it’s my favorite roadtrip podcast. So you can imagine how excited I was when I learned that my favorite podcast was coming back! But the new hosts are just not it… it’s hard to get through the new episodes. It doesn’t feel like the original podcast at all and sounds more like a storytelling podcast for children.. the back and forth dialogue is so forced (unlike Ashley and Brit on Crime Junkie). Their voices are not adequate for a spooky/mysterious podcast. Definitely bummed that it’s no longer the podcast I know and love 😔

The new hosts are so annoying. There’s not one episode where they don’t mention that they’re sisters, their mom, Hawaii or something bringing back to themselves. It’s a joke now when I say “they’re going to talk about themselves or mention they’re from Hawaii now” and it happens. Ashley has listeners so captivated and wanting more! Please bring her back to host!!

I really don’t know what everybody else is talking about. I mean, I miss Ashley as much as the next person, but I think the new host are lovely and they sound great! Especially with their mom, apparently believing in all of the ghost stuff, I think they’re perfect fits!

Enjoyed the show until new host joined. Why these host always make themselves part of the story. Show is soo annoying

Wish it was just Ashley hosting still, show isn’t as good as it used to be, can’t stand listening to newer episodes with the new hosts.

The Loch Ness monster! Finally! I love this mystery!!! 🤗🤗😁😁😁🥳🥳🥳🥳🥳🥳🥳 I listened to this podcast since I was seven! I’m still pretty young but I love these mysteries! Btw Yvette and Rasha you go! ;)

Is this meant to be narrated as if the audience is learning colors and numbers? The tone is very leading and the hosts kind of aren’t fun to listen to.

Really good! Love the one on Healing Waters. Please one on Atlantis soon? 😄

Fantastic podcast, I started with the first episode and am now all caught up. Looking forward to the next episode!!!

Ok this is so stupid now.

I agree with basically all of the current reviews…the new hosts don’t do this show justice.

The new hosts are ok. I adore Ashley as the host. She catches my attention and holds it.

I’ve held off posting a review on this…in prayer that it would get better. But here I am. Years ago now…this show was my gateway drug into podcasts as a whole…prior to even knowing about Crime Junkie, Ashley Flowers, or anything related (also, please bring back It’s a Wonderful Lie, I beg you) I was promptly obsessed. When I heard it was coming back…I was beside myself. Then the baton was handed off to what seem like genuinely nice people, (but those people have never read anything aloud other than their children’s bedtime stories to put them to sleep) and woof. I keep trying to get past it…and alas, I cannot. I understand that Ashley is busy, and the need for a new host is acceptable (I did desperately root for the new hosts)…but I have to be honest, it is not a fit. Please, please, please either help them with podcast reading training, Ashley come back, or find a host who has the gravitas to carry the topics of this show so that it doesn’t disappear again!!!

This show was great when Ashley had it and I was SO excited it was coming back… but the new girls are horrible and annoying, esp the older sounding one. I am so interested in these topics, but the hosts are horrible!! I can’t even listen and pay attention even if it is a story I am super interested in. What a letdown. I really want Ashley to take this one back. Ashley…if you read this, please save us from these hosts bc the stories are great, the people telling them are just awful!!!! Unsubscribing from this one til the hosts are changed or Ashley takes it back! Update… months later I decided to give this podcast another try as it is a topic I am interested in, and again I am even more blown away at how horrible these hosts are!! I couldn’t even get through the first 30 seconds!

I love this show I feel like there are to many adds maybe limit it down to 2 per episode

The amount of conspiracy theories and unscientific nonsense mentioned and spoken as truth (crystals) is insane… I like the UFO ones but everything else is taken too far into misinformation…

I love the hosts, how they get personal, and their banter. Keep up the great work! I love this show. Please keep being authentic.

If this podcast was narrated by someone other than the current hosts I would be so happy with it. The speed at which they talk and the tone makes it hard to listen to. I’m sorry!!

I get that this is a podcast about the weird and unexplained, but in the “UFOs in the Hudson Valley” episode when they mentioned Bethany Frankel, it was the last straw. You lost ALL credibility with that one. I can’t listen to this anymore.

The new hosts are ok, but I agree with everyone else when I say we miss Ashley Flowers and that there’s too many personal stories and scripted banter. But overall, the essence is still there. One thing I cannot abide is the overuse of “literal” or “LIT-UH-RUH-LEE”.

It’s one thing to have a “supernatural” podcasts that explores possibilities of unexplained events by discussing supernatural explanations. It’s a completely different thing to push your personal beliefs of conspiracy theories and completely dismiss legitimate explanations as “lies”, “excuses”, “practical jokes”, and “conspiracies”. This is blatant misinformation and science denial. Be better, I loved listening to Audiochuck Productions and I don’t want to have to stop.

The new hosts make this a really hard listen. This was one of my absolute favorite podcasts but since the switch up I just cannot get through it. Seems like every episode somehow gets circled back to something that happened in their personal lives? Idk it’s odd and I’m not a fan. Ashley come back!!

SUPPOSEDLY

Way too many adds

Man I can’t stop listening to this podcast I just wanted to tell you guys that I appreciate you and I love the videos that you guys make please make us more videos 😀

I have to agree with others. This was my husband and I’s favorite podcasts when Ashley hosted, and we were SO sad when she stopped. When I saw it was started back up we were seriously so excited, but I honestly just can’t get through any of the new episodes. The personal stories and little banter back and forth is so staged and feels forced. We still listen to the podcast all the time, but only the old episodes where Ashley is the narrator.

Thoroughly enjoyed the podcast until the April 4th 2025 episode Aliens in the Hudson Valley when the hosts decided to push weather related conspiracy theories on listeners. In this day and age when science (especially meteorology) is under attack pushing baseless conspiracy theories is dangerous and harmful. Fog forms in winter it is as simple as that. There is no conspiracy theory it was just fog. I’ve listened to this show since the original run but I’m unfollowing and will no longer be listening. I cannot support a show that encourages baseless conspiracy theories that only increase distrust in scientists.

seeing the stars in heaven $ knowing they all have a beautiful beginning !

I tried so hard to like it. The content is so good, but the hosts need a lot more practice. They speak so slow, I had to check and make sure I didn’t accidentally put it on 1/2 speed. Rather than being themselves, they try to mimic Ashley Flowers and it makes it sound inauthentic. They also sound like they are reading scripts word for word. I know most podcasts have a script, but you have to make it sound like you’re not reading. Some of the episodes have sounded so interesting but I can’t make it through bc of the hosts. I really am not trying to be mean, just be honest.

Have to agree with many of the other commenters. I’ve listened to Ashley’s voice for hours in the the previous seasons. Heard all the episodes far more often than I’ll openly admit. The new format simply isn’t working for your core audience. It feels like scripted “girl time” and has very little of what the show used to deliver. Really tried to like the relaunch - slogged through the first 10 episodes- but the co hosts are simply distracting and add very little value. Can’t Ashley just come back and be amazing all by herself?

I just dunno whether it is fake or not I mean it sound real it is tooooo supernatural

I feel really bad saying this but with the new hosts I just can’t listen. I think the new hosts should start a children’s spooky story podcast. They seem lovely but not for this podcast. Has totally changed the vibe, and I loved it before when it was Ashley.

The new so supernatural is great and I love how much more information is given. Finished listening to La Llorona and it’s so nice to hear them pronounce her name right and speak Spanish good! I also loved the night marchers episode too! You can tell it was close to the girls hearts. :)

Should have just left it alone if she wasn’t going to be hosting it. I cannot stand the hosts voices and the way they tell the story.

One of my favorite podcasts, it is so much fun and very interesting. They cover everything from UFOs to Bigfoot and ghost stories.

Supernatural was my favorite podcast of all time when Ashley hosted it. It seriously got me through the pandemic! I was so happy when I heard Audio Chuck purchased Supernatural, I couldn’t wait to hear new episodes!! I was so disappointed when I heard the new hosts, they are terrible. They sound like nails on a chalkboard, I tried I really tried but they sound so scripted. Sounds like they are just reading off a script that was handed to them. Such a shame! Wish Ashley would come back and host the entire show!!!!!!